Left Isis
Right Isis
             

November 18th, 2026

My cherished Tell Me Your Story guest for November is historical mystery author Mary Louisa Locke. Growing up in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, Mary Lou had two goals: to teach history and to write novels that would bring others the joy that Georgette Heyer’s historical romances and Mary Stewart’s suspense novels brought her. After earning degrees in history from Oberlin College and Kent State University, she headed west with her husband to obtain a doctorate in history from U.C. San Diego. Throughout those years she continued to read historical fiction and the growing work of women writing mysteries and science fiction, daydreaming about writing someday. She spent the next ten years finishing her doctorate, raising a daughter, and teaching at a series of colleges in the southwest while working on the first draft of Maids of Misfortune. In 2009, Maids of Misfortune was a finalist in the historical fiction category of the 2010 Next Generation Indie Book Awards and in July 2010 rose to the historical mystery best seller list on Kindle. Sales of the book were strong enough that after a 20 year career teaching at San Diego Mesa Community College, she retired from teaching completely and began to write full time. As of 2026, Mary Lou has published six more novels in the series (Bloody Lessons, Deadly Proof, Pilfered Promises, Scholarly Pursuits, Lethal Remedies, and the latest, Entangled Threads) along with six novellas, and eight short stories, all set in this series. She is currently working on the ninth novel in the series, Etched in Blood.

How Persistence Paid Off
by Mary Louisa Locke

Like many a writer’s origin story, my dream of becoming an author started early, fostered by being read to by my parents and then becoming an insatiable reader myself. However, I can see that the first milestone in my journey to becoming a historical fiction writer came when my parents read four books to me by the award-winning children’s author, Kate Seredy.

These books were The Good Master and its sequel, The Singing Tree, which were about a farm family in Hungary before and during WWI. The other two books were The Open Gate, which was set in the United States at the end of the Depression and the beginning of WWII and The Chestry Oak, which was set during WWII, first in Hungary and then in the United States. I loved this last book so much, that, at the age of 5, I learned how to read so I could reread it over and over.

Besides having boys and girls as the main protagonists, Seredy’s books (written in the 1930s and 40s) did an excellent job of describing the effect historical world events (like war, antisemitism and other forms of prejudice, the Great Depression, and the move from farms to factories) had on ordinary individuals. That became a touchstone in my journey to become both a professional historian and an author of historical fiction.

(I confess until I wrote this essay, I didn’t make the connection between Seredy’s books, especially The Open Gate, and the fact that I read and loved all ten of Casey’s Alafair Tucker Mystery series, which introduce many of the same themes.)

The second important milestone came when I was thirteen and had to write a “career paper” my freshman year in high school. I chose writing as my career, and one of the three writers I interviewed was Gladys Schmitt, who had just published the bestselling book, Rembrandt. This experience cemented my belief that it was possible for a woman to become a successful fiction author. On the other hand, all three authors said it was practically impossible to make a living as a fiction writer. In short, they advised me to plan on having a day job. For Schmitt, this was being an English professor at Carnegie Mellon University, a model for my own future that I took seriously.

Therefore, in 1967, when I started Oberlin college, I assumed my day job was going to be teaching, which meant I could major in literature or history. Since my goal still was to write historical fiction, this was an easy choice. I majored in history for my BA at Oberlin. Then, five years later, I went on to get my doctorate in history at University of California, San Diego.

The third milestone in my journey came when I decided to study a relatively new field of history, called social history. My doctoral courses in this field were all about the experiences of ordinary people, including African-Americans, immigrants, women, and the working classes. My dissertation was on the women who worked in the urban far west at the end of the 19th century. Not famous women, but the ordinary working women the census takers of 1880 counted, taking down their names, their birthdates, their occupations, their race and ethnicity, and the details of the people they lived with, including their families, other boarders, or employers.

As I worked on that dissertation, I realized I was not going to be content to simply put out a dry manuscript, which would only be read by a handful of other academics. Instead, I started to dream about turning the facts about these real women into historical fiction, which would be read by the general public. But what kind of historical fiction?

What I was reading for recreation as I worked on my history doctorate in the were mysteries. Not historical mysteries, because in the 1970s, this wasn’t a recognized mystery sub-genre. The only example I had discovered was Ellis Peter’s Morbid Taste for Bones, the first book in the Brother Cadfael series, published in 1977.

What I was reading were the mysteries by women like Agatha Christie, Ngaio Marsh, Margery Allingham, Josephine Tey, and Dorothy Sayers who were writing in the period between World War I and World War II (called the Golden Age of detective fiction.) While these writers were writing contemporary mysteries, to me, forty years later, they were historical. And when I read Dorothy Sayer’s Gaudy Night, I found the model for what would eventually become my Victorian San Francisco Mystery series.

Sayers wrote a series featuring Lord Peter Wimsey, about an amateur detective. Unusual for the period, four of the books introduced a female protagonist, Harriet Vane, to the series. Having two equal protagonists was alone unusual, but Gaudy Night combined this element with a solid mystery plot, and a specific historical setting (England after World War One) that was integral to the plot. In addition, the struggle between Vane and Wimsey to become equal partners, provided a romantic tension that reminded me of my young adult love of the Regency romances by Georgette Heyer.

I have consciously used these elements: a solid mystery plot, two amateur sleuths (in my case, Annie Fuller a widowed boarding house owner and Nate Dawson, a local lawyer,) a specific historical setting (San Francisco in the 1880s), and the romantic tension between Annie and Nate as they struggle to maintain an equal partnership in a period that was even more patriarchal than Sayer’s England between WWI and WWII.

Yet, despite now having a plan, there still was that need to have that pesky day job as a professor of history. As a result, I didn’t get a chance to write the first draft of the first book in my projected series, Maids of Misfortune, until ten years later when I had a year in between teaching positions. I wrote the book, immediately got an agent, who rapidly obtained rejections from all the major publishers. The rejections graciously said they liked the book but already had one historical mystery in their line-up, and they weren’t sure there was the market for more.

This definitely confirmed the wisdom of having a day job to fall back on because, fortuitously, along with the rejections of Maids of Misfortune, I was offered the position I would hold for the next 20 years as a full-time professor of US history and women’s history at a local community college.

This job was very satisfying, and I did get to do lectures occasionally on my urban working women. I also continued to tinker with Maids of Misfortune, even starting to write a second book in the series, Uneasy Spirits. This was my way of not giving up on the dream, although the journey was taking longer than I ever could imagine.

This brings us to the final milestone in my journey, when I retired and decided to forgo the traditional publishing route and become an indie author and self-publish. A member of a writers’ group, I had watched fellow mystery authors, who had been traditionally published, get beaten down by this system, so I had no desire to give this route another try. The Kindle and Amazon’s Kindle Direct Publishing platform had recently been rolled out, so I now had an alternative way to get the stories of my marvelous western working women out to the world.

As a result, thirty years after I came up with the plot and twenty years after I wrote the first draft, I published Maids of Misfortune. I used a “how to self-publish” book that was available in 2009, I paid a friend $250 to create a cover, set up a free website, and launched the book as both an ebook and a paperback, and hoped someone would notice.

Thankfully, readers did. As an early adapter of ebooks, I had few competitors, and few traditional publishers bothered to put any of their books into the relatively new historical mystery category in on-line bookstores. As a result, readers discovered Maids of Misfortune, and their positive reviews encouraged me to write more stories about my working women.

Since then, I have published eight novels and another thirteen novellas and short stories in the Victorian San Francisco mystery series. In these books there are women who are domestic servants, boarding house keepers, trance mediums and fake fortunetellers, seamstresses, hat makers, dress makers, type setters, public school teachers, nurses, doctors, store clerks, factory workers, university students, charity workers, lawyers, and even former prostitutes. All of these characters are based on the women I encountered in my dissertation research nearly fifty years ago. I had finally arrived at my destination.

Since Maids of Misfortune came out, over 300,000 people have bought one of the books in the series, and counting the books readers got for free in the promotional discounts I do routinely, over 2,000,000 people have had the chance to learn about what life was like for the real women who lived and worked in the cities of the far west in the last decades of the 19th century.

While my dream had been long deferred, the journey has certainly been worth it. And since I am currently at work on Etched in Blood, the ninth novel in the series, which will feature women artists and illustrators, you can see, I haven’t decided to end the journey quite yet.

__________

Visit Mary Louisa at https://mlouisalocke.com/